Local search
Google Business Profile vs Website: Do You Need Both?
Yes. The profile is how a local customer finds you on the map. The website is where they decide. Here is what each one does, what Google says decides local results, and which to set up first.
By SyX SolutionsPublished November 9, 20266 min readA local business needs both a Google Business Profile and a website, because they do different jobs. The profile gets you seen by people nearby who do not know your name. The website is what convinces them, and it is what people who already know your name go looking for.
That is the short answer. The rest of this article shows it with one client’s real numbers, quotes what Google itself says about local results, and tells you which to set up first.
What each one actually does
| Google Business Profile | Your website | |
|---|---|---|
| Where it shows | Google Maps and the local results at the top of a search. | The regular search results, and anywhere someone shares or types your address. |
| Who it reaches | People nearby searching for a service, who may not know you. | People who searched your name, clicked through from the profile, or searched something specific you have a page for. |
| What you control | Your details, photos, posts and replies. Google controls the layout and shows competitors beside you. | Everything. It is the one place a customer sees only your business. |
| What it captures | Calls, direction requests and website clicks. | Bookings, forms and chats, saved in your own system with the details attached. |
The takeaway: a website without an active profile is hard to discover. A profile without a website has nowhere to send the customer who wants to know more before they call.
What Google says decides local results
Google states that local results are based mainly on relevance, distance and prominence. Relevance is how well a profile matches the search. Distance is how far the business is from the searcher. Prominence is how well known the business is, and Google says it draws on information such as how many websites link to the business and how many reviews it has. Source: Google Business Profile Help, tips to improve your local ranking.
You cannot change distance. You can change the other two, and the website feeds both. Clear service pages tell Google what you are relevant for. A real site gives directories, suppliers and local organisations something to link to.
The same holds for AI answers. Google’s guidance on its generative AI features says they can include information about local businesses, and that a Business Profile helps a business be visible there. Source: Google Search Central, guide to optimizing for generative AI features.
Which to set up first
- Claim and verify the Google Business Profile. It is free and verification takes time, so start it first.
- Fill it in completely. Categories, services, hours, service area, real photos. An empty profile is a weak one.
- Launch the website with matching details. The same name, address, phone number and hours, written the same way.
- Link them. The profile points to the site and to your booking page. The site links to the profile and shows the reviews.
- Ask for reviews after every finished job. Ask every customer, not only the happy ones. Reply to each one.
- Add pages as the data tells you to. One page per service people search for, and area pages where you have real work to show.
When a profile alone is enough
If you are booked solid from repeat customers and referrals, and you do not want new ones, a complete profile may be all you need for now. A website earns its place when you want customers who have not heard of you, when you want to be chosen for a specific service, or when you want every enquiry saved in a system you own instead of scattered across calls and messages.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need a website if I have a Google Business Profile?
Yes, if you want customers who do not already know you. The profile gets you seen on the map. The website answers the questions the profile cannot, lets a customer book or enquire, and gives Google and AI assistants the detail they use to decide what your business is relevant for.
Which should a new local business set up first?
The Google Business Profile, because it is free, it is what appears in Google Maps and local results, and verification takes time. Then the website, with the same name, address, phone number, hours and services, so the two confirm each other.
Can a Google Business Profile replace a website?
Not well. You do not control the layout, you cannot add a page for each service or area, and you cannot capture a lead in your own system. A profile also shows competitors next to you. Your website is the one place a customer sees only your business.
Does a website help my Google Maps ranking?
Google says local results are based on relevance, distance and prominence, and that prominence draws on information such as how many websites link to your business and how many reviews you have. A website with clear service pages helps with relevance and gives other sites something to link to. It is one input, not a switch.
Sources
Keep reading
Where to go from here.
Start here
See what customers find when they search for you.
Thirty minutes. We look at your profile and your site side by side, the way a new customer does, and tell you what is worth fixing first.
Want the numbers on the phone side first? Run the missed call calculator.